But the guy at the gun store said I need to get a revolver........

I have seen on several occasions that well meaning gun store employees, or customers at the store that think they are being helpful, tell new shooters (especially women) that they need a revolver.  Now if you've been following Cold War Concealment on social media, you know that one of my primary carry guns is a Ruger LCR, so I'm definitely not someone who is going to trash talk revolvers.  Instead, lets just take a solid look at pros and cons of a small revolver, like the Ruger LCR or the Smith & Wesson J-Frame.

Starting with the revolvers:


  1. Simplicity and Reliability: Revolvers are known for their inherent reliability. With fewer moving parts than semi-automatic pistols, they are less prone to malfunctions or jamming.
  2. Ease of Use: Revolvers are generally simpler to operate, making them easier to learn for beginners or those with limited firearm experience.
  3. Durability: Revolvers are often built to withstand heavy use and harsh conditions, making them durable and long-lasting.
  4. Versatility in Ammunition: Revolvers can typically fire a variety of ammunition types, including different bullet profiles and power levels.
  5. Intuitive Point-and-Shoot: Revolvers have a straightforward point-and-shoot operation, as the shooter only needs to pull the trigger to fire each round.


  1. Limited Capacity: Revolvers have a limited number of rounds, typically ranging from five to eight, depending on the model. Reloading requires individually inserting each cartridge into the cylinder.
  2. Slower Reload Speed: Reloading a revolver is slower and more cumbersome compared to semi-automatic pistols. This can be a disadvantage in situations where a quick reload is necessary.
  3. Recoil and Control: Revolvers tend to have more recoil due to the placement of the barrel higher above the shooter's hand. This can make it more challenging to manage recoil and maintain accuracy during rapid-fire or follow-up shots.
  4. Limited Accessories: Revolvers have fewer accessory options compared to semi-automatic pistols. They typically lack the accessory rails found on many semi-autos, limiting the ability to attach lights, lasers, or other accessories.

Semi-Automatic Pistol:


  1. Larger Capacity: Semi-automatic pistols generally offer higher capacities, allowing for more rounds before the need to reload.
  2. Faster Reload Speed: Reloading a semi-automatic pistol is quicker and more efficient compared to a revolver. Magazines can be pre-loaded and easily inserted into the firearm.
  3. Compact and Concealable: Semi-automatic pistols come in various sizes, including compact and subcompact options, making them easier to conceal for everyday carry.
  4. Recoil Management: The design of semi-automatic pistols, with the lower bore axis often allows for better recoil management and faster follow-up shots.
  5. Accessory Compatibility: Semi-automatic pistols often have accessory rails, allowing for the attachment of lights, lasers, or other accessories to enhance versatility and customization.


  1. Potential for Malfunctions: Semi-automatic pistols have more moving parts, increasing the likelihood of malfunctions due to factors such as ammunition issues, improper maintenance, or a weak grip on the firearm.
  2. Learning Curve: Operating a semi-automatic pistol effectively may require more training and practice compared to revolvers, especially for beginners.
  3. Maintenance Requirements: Semi-automatic pistols typically require more regular cleaning and maintenance to ensure optimal performance and reliability.
  4. Magazine Dependent: Semi-automatic pistols rely on magazines to function, and if a magazine malfunctions or is lost, the firearm becomes inoperable until a replacement is obtained.
  5. Complexity: The operation of semi-automatic pistols involves additional considerations, such as slide manipulation, external safeties, and potential malfunctions, which may require troubleshooting skills and additional training.

PERSONAL OPINION ALERT: As I mentioned before, I carry my Ruger LCR revolver more than my other carry guns.  I find it much more comfortable to carry due to the rounded shape of the grip, and I do shoot it quite well.  While the trigger on a revolver requires more force to pull than a semi-automatic pistol, it is by no means unmanageable.  So while you shouldn't let someone talk you into buying a revolver just because you're a new shooter, or because you're a woman, it might just be what suits you best.

Ultimately, the choice between a revolver and a semi-automatic pistol depends on individual preferences, intended use, and comfort level. Consider factors such as reliability, capacity, ease of use, concealability, and shooting characteristics when selecting the firearm that best suits your needs and circumstances. Additionally, hands-on experience and professional instruction can provide valuable insights to help you make an informed decision.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published